Updated: September 30, 2024- 18 min read
Even veterans in product and project management can find themselves confused about where their roles start to overlap. Thus, it's not uncommon for a project manager to find themselves tangled in product strategy discussions. Sometimes, product managers dive too deep into project timelines.
In a scenario where a product launch is around the corner, things get even blurier. Both roles are essential, but both Product Management roles and project management teams report toe-stepping and even conflict that derives from the clumsy tango.
In this article, we’ll clarify the distinct roles and responsibilities of product managers and project managers. We’ll highlight where they intersect, where it’s normal to expect some shared activities, and where they diverge.
Whether you're already in one of these roles or considering a shift between them, we’ll explore what sets these career paths apart. We’ll see how they collaborate and how to navigate a transition from project management to product management if that's on your radar.
Let’s break down these roles to clear up any lingering confusion.
Product Launch Checklist
Launch is a critical time that can make the difference between product success and failure. Use this checklist to make sure nothing falls through the cracks.
DOWNLOAD CHECKLIST
First Things First, How Are Projects Different From Products?
Projects are time-bound, with a fixed scope, timeline, and budget, aiming to deliver a specific outcome. In contrast, products are goods or services developed to satisfy the needs of a group of users.
Building a new smartphone model is a project—it has a set timeline, budget, and specific features to deliver.
However, the smartphone itself is a product. After launch, it evolves through software updates, feature enhancements, and user feedback.
Difference Between Project Manager and Product Manager
“I see kind of the role of product managers as trying to build consensus around the right decisions, using inputs from peers, using inputs from data, from research, from their own product sense, and then trying to build consensus as quickly as possible.” — Jeremy Forrester, VP Product at Twitch, on The Product Podcast
Focus and Objectives
Product managers are the visionaries behind the product. Their primary goal is to define what the product should be, why it matters to the market, and how it aligns with the company’s strategic goals.
They are responsible for the product's success — from ideation to launch and beyond. Their responsibility involves market research, customer needs analysis, and creating a Product Roadmap that aligns with business objectives.
Project managers focus on the how and the when. They are the planners and executors, ensuring that projects—whether they involve Product Development or other initiatives—are delivered on time, within scope, and on budget. Their role revolves around planning and coordination, making sure the process is efficient and meets the set objectives.
Roles and Responsibilities
Product managers define the product vision, strategy, and roadmap. They gather and prioritize customer requirements, work with cross-functional teams like engineering, design, and marketing, and act as the voice of the customer throughout the product's lifecycle.
They make decisions about product features, set pricing strategies, and often play a role in marketing and sales. Their success is measured by how well the product meets market needs and achieves business goals.
Project managers focus on delivering projects that meet requirements within defined constraints. They create detailed project plans, allocate resources, monitor progress, and handle any issues or changes that arise.
They ensure everyone knows their tasks and deadlines, using product frameworks like Agile, Scrum, or CIRCLES to keep things on track. Their success is measured by the project's ability to meet its objectives within the agreed scope, time, and budget.
Time Frame and Scope
Product managers operate with a long-term perspective. The product lifecycle can span years, and they are involved in the ongoing evolution of the product. They continuously refine the product based on user research, market trends, Product Analytics, and Product Strategy. Their scope is broad and strategic, encompassing the entire product ecosystem.
Project managers work within a clearly defined time frame, typically short- to medium-term. A project has a start and end, with clear deliverables and a set timeline. Once the project is completed, they move on to the next initiative. Their scope is tactical, focusing on delivering specific outcomes within the project's constraints.
Collaboration and Teams
Product managers collaborate across various departments, including engineering, design, marketing, sales, and customer support. They lead by influence instead of authority.
They guide teams to build products that align with the product vision and user needs. Their role is about driving a shared understanding of the product's goals and features.
Project managers also work with cross-functional teams, but their focus is on coordination and execution. They ensure that team members have what they need to complete their tasks on time and that everyone remains aligned with the project's timeline.
Their role is more about managing people and processes in order to deliver the project on time.
Metrics of Success
Product managers are evaluated based on product-related metrics such as customer satisfaction, Product Adoption rates, revenue growth, market share, and return on investment (ROI). They are accountable for the product's overall impact on the business and how well it meets market demands.
Project managers are evaluated based on the success of the project itself. Key metrics include on-time delivery, staying within budget, meeting the project's scope, and stakeholder satisfaction. Their focus is on efficiency, quality of execution, and adherence to the project plan.
Decision-Making and Authority
Product managers have the final say in product decisions. They decide what features to prioritize, when to pivot, and how to position the product in the market. Their decisions are driven by customer insights, data analysis, and strategic alignment with business goals. This gives them significant influence over the product's direction.
In general, the hierarchy within product management roles appears to be more complex. Various Product Management positions cover different levels of seniority, each with distinct responsibilities.
Project managers have authority over the execution phase. They make crucial decisions about how to achieve project goals, such as adjusting timelines or reallocating resources. However, they typically don't alter the product vision or scope significantly. Their role is to ensure that the project delivers what has been defined by the Product Principal, Product Leadership, and other stakeholders.
The hierarchy for project managers tends to be a bit less complex compared to product managers. While there are different levels of project management roles, such as junior, senior, and Program Managers, the range of roles and the distinctions between them are usually not as varied or nuanced as in Product Management.
Typical Challenges
Product managers often struggle with balancing competing priorities, feature creep, advocating Product Frameworks, managing stakeholder expectations, and aligning teams around the same goals. They need to be strategic thinkers and effective communicators. Therefore, constant adaption to market changes and refinements to the product are crucial.
Project managers frequently face challenges related to resource constraints, scope creep, tight deadlines, and unforeseen risks. They need to manage complexity, problem-solve on the fly, and keep teams on track to deliver the project successfully. Their focus is on mitigating risks and ensuring that the project progresses smoothly within the set parameters.
Product Management vs Project Management: Example Project Breakdown
Let's dive into this sample project to help you better grasp the nuanced differences in these two roles — their responsibilities and where they might overlap. For this example, we’ll “launch a Sudoku mobile game.”
In the development and launch of this mobile game, the roles of the product manager (PM) and the project manager (PjM) will intertwine and work hand-in-hand. Let’s see how exactly:
Product Manager (PM): Shaping the Game Vision
The PM would be the visionary behind this enhanced Sudoku game. Their primary focus would be on defining what the game should be and why it matters to users. In this case, the PM's responsibilities would include:
User Research and Market Analysis: The PM would begin by researching the market for Sudoku games, analyzing competitor apps on Play and App Stores, and identifying user pain points. For this game, they might discover that while users enjoy Sudoku, they often find it repetitive and lacking in social interaction. The PM would use these insights to define a unique value proposition — introducing competitive leaderboards to boost player retention and shareability.
Product Strategy and Vision: Based on the research, the PM would craft a Product Vision focused on creating a Sudoku game that isn't just about solving puzzles but also about competing and connecting with others. The leaderboards, daily challenges, and monthly leagues would be central to this vision.
Feature Prioritization: The PM would prioritize features based on the Product Vision. In this case, the core gameplay (Sudoku puzzles) would come first, followed by competitive elements like daily challenges, leaderboards, and league systems. The PM would decide how these features are rolled out in phases, perhaps starting with daily challenges and gradually introducing monthly leagues.
User Experience (UX) and Design: Working closely with UX and Product Designers, the PM would define the digital user journey, ensuring that the app's interface is intuitive and engaging. They'd focus on how players navigate from puzzle-solving to checking leaderboards, ensuring the transition is seamless and rewarding.
KPI Definition and Measurement: The PM would establish Objectives and Key Results (OKRs) to measure success. These would be player retention rates, average session length, and leaderboard participation. They also track engagement with the new competitive elements to gauge if these features are driving the desired user behavior.
Project Manager (PjM): Orchestrating the Execution
While the PM focuses on what and why, the PjM concentrates on how and when. The PjM would be responsible for ensuring that the development of the game happens on time, within scope, and on budget. Here’s what that looks like:
Project Planning: The PjM would focus on the product vision, such as launching a key feature and breaking it down into actionable tasks. They'd create a detailed project plan for this feature, outlining the development timeline, key dependencies, and milestones. This could include coding the puzzle generator, implementing difficulty settings, and initial user testing.
Resource Allocation: The PjM would ensure that the right team members—developers, designers, and testers—are allocated to the appropriate tasks. They'd identify potential bottlenecks, such as the complexity of implementing real-time leaderboards, and adjust resources as needed.
Risk Management: Foreseeing potential risks, such as delays in the backend setup for leaderboard data processing, falls under the PjM's purview. They would develop contingency plans to address these issues without derailing the project timeline.
Progress Tracking and Reporting: The PjM would monitor the project's progress, ensuring tasks are completed on schedule. They’d also keep stakeholders, including the PM, informed through regular status updates, using project management tools to track the team's progress.
Where Their Duties Overlap
In an Agile setting, the PM and PjM would collaborate closely to ensure that the product vision aligns with the project's execution. Here’s where their roles might intersect:
Sprint Planning: During sprint planning sessions, the PM would outline the priority features or user stories (e.g., the leaderboard's functionality). The PjM would then break these down into specific tasks, assigning them to team members. Together, they’d ensure that the Sprint Backlog aligns with the Product Roadmap.
Daily Standups: In daily standups, the PM might focus on clarifying any questions about the features being developed, such as the leaderboard's rules. Meanwhile, the PjM would ensure that team members have the resources they need to meet their daily goals and address any blockers.
Agile Retrospectives: After each sprint, the PM and PjM would join the Agile Retrospective to evaluate what went well and what could be improved. The PM might discuss whether the implemented features met user expectations, while the PjM would focus on the efficiency of the development process. Together, they’d brainstorm ways to streamline future sprints.
Design Sprint Template
Use design thinking to solve design problems and reduce production risks.
GET THE TEMPLATE
Team Dynamics
In the development of this Sudoku game, the PM would often work with designers and the marketing team to ensure the game aligns with Product Experience goals and the overall Marketing strategy.
For example, they’d collaborate with designers on the visual aspects of the leaderboard to make it engaging and competitive. Simultaneously, they’d provide input to the marketing team on how to promote the new competitive features.
On the other hand, the PjM would coordinate with developers, QA testers, and possibly the operations team. They’d ensure that developers understand the technical requirements for features like real-time leaderboard updates and that testers have clear test cases to validate the leaderboard’s accuracy and performance.
Communication Flow
Product Manager to Project Manager: The PM communicates the product vision and priorities to the PjM. For instance, they might explain that the daily challenges are critical to launch first because they’re expected to drive initial user engagement.
Project Manager to Product Manager: The PjM provides feedback on timelines, feasibility, and any potential issues. If integrating the leaderboards takes longer than expected, the PjM will inform the PM so they can re-evaluate the feature rollout plan.
Project Manager vs. Product Manager: A Day in the Life
The PM might spend the morning analyzing user feedback from the beta release of the game. They may find out that players love the daily challenges but find the leaderboard UI confusing. They’d then meet with the Product Designer to discuss improvements, followed by a session with the marketing team to align the upcoming feature launch with promotional strategies.
PjM’s Day: Meanwhile, the PjM would start their day reviewing the sprint progress. They may notice that the leaderboard integration is behind schedule. They’d facilitate a quick meeting with the development team to identify the roadblock and reallocate resources if necessary. Later, they'd update the project timeline and communicate these changes to the PM and other stakeholders.
How to Pursue a Career as a Product Manager
If you’re interested in becoming a Product Manager, you'll want to start by building a solid foundation in business, technology, or design—basically anything that gives you insight into how products are built and marketed. A common path is starting in roles like marketing, UX design, or software development, where you can get hands-on experience with Product Development challenges.
Many PMs also pursue degrees in business or computer science, but it’s not strictly necessary.
Once you've got some experience under your belt, focus on learning the ins and outs of Product Management. This means understanding market research, product experience, product strategy, and working with cross-functional teams. Taking online courses, attending workshops, and obtaining certifications in product management can really boost your resume. Look for opportunities to get involved in product-related projects, whether it’s within your current job or through side projects.
There are plenty more tips to help you get started if you're aiming for a career as a Product Manager.
Transitioning from Project Manager to Product Manager
To transition from project manager to product manager, start by gaining a deep understanding of product strategy, user research, and market analysis. The good thing is that you can leverage your existing skills in project execution and cross-functional collaboration.
Seek opportunities to work closely with product teams and engage in conversations with PMs on a regular basis. Try to understand their mindset and concerns and how they differ from yours.
If possible, try to ask for permission to participate in product planning and development. Consider taking courses in product management or obtaining certifications to level up.
Highlight transferable skills, such as stakeholder management and problem-solving, on your resume. Networking with current product managers and seeking mentorship can also provide valuable insights and guidance for making the switch to a product-focused role.
How to Pursue a Career as a Project Manager
Starting a career as a Project Manager typically involves a bit more focus on process and organization. Many project managers come from backgrounds in business, operations, or engineering. If you’re in a role where you’re already handling tasks like scheduling, budgeting, or coordinating teams, you’re on the right track. A degree in business, engineering, or even communications can be helpful since these fields teach you the skills you’ll use in managing projects.
To really get your foot in the door, consider gaining some project management knowledge through courses or certifications that are considered widely credible. These credentials can help you understand project management methodologies like Agile and show potential employers that you know your craft.
Look for opportunities to manage small projects in your current job to build practical experience. This could be anything from coordinating a team project to leading a small event. The goal is to show you can take a project from start to finish and keep everything on track. As with Product Management, networking is key. Join project management groups, attend meetups, and connect with other PjMs to learn from their experiences.
When you’re ready to make the leap, seek out roles like Project Coordinator or Junior Project Manager. These positions are great starting points. They will give you the experience you need to move up to managing larger and more complex projects down the road.
Expected Salaries for Project Management and Product Management
When comparing salaries for project management and product management roles, there are noticeable differences influenced by factors like seniority, location, and industry. Here’s a detailed look.
Project Management Salaries
Average Salary: The average salary for a Project Manager in the United States is $89,339 per year, according to Indeed. This can vary significantly depending on experience and location. Entry-level roles, like Junior Project Manager, have an average salary of $65,145 per year, while more advanced roles, like Senior Project Manager, command an average salary of $117,716 annually.
Entry-Level Roles:
Associate Project Manager: With an average salary of $69,182 per year, this is a common starting point for those entering the project management field. The role usually involves supporting more senior project managers and handling smaller projects.
Entry Level Project Manager: Typically earning around $60,617 per year, individuals in this position are responsible for managing smaller-scale projects and assisting in larger project planning and execution.
Mid-Level Roles:
Project Manager: At the mid-level, project managers earn an average of $89,339 per year, with salaries ranging from $56,791 to $140,541, depending on experience and the complexity of projects they manage.
Advanced Roles:
Lead Project Manager: With an average salary of $101,670 per year, lead project managers take on more responsibility, often managing larger, more complex projects and leading project teams.
Senior Project Manager: A more experienced role, senior project managers earn an average of $117,716 annually, focusing on high-stakes projects and often guiding multiple project teams.
Principal Project Manager: At the top of the ladder, principal project managers can earn an average of $131,227 per year. These professionals typically oversee project portfolios, lead strategic initiatives, and play a key role in shaping project management practices within their organization.
Highest Paying Locations: Project managers tend to earn more in cities like Seattle, WA ($103,291 per year), Washington, DC ($103,285 per year), and Los Angeles, CA ($102,686 per year). Factors like cost of living and demand for project management skills in these areas contribute to higher salaries.
Product Management Salaries
Average Salary: Product managers in the United States earn a higher average salary compared to project managers, with an average of $120,872 per year. Additionally, they often receive a cash bonus, averaging around $5,000 annually. The variation in salary for product managers can be substantial, with entry-level roles starting lower and senior roles reaching well into six figures.
Entry-Level Roles:
Associate Product Manager: The starting point for many in product management is that associate product managers earn an average of $82,399 per year. They typically assist with market research, product planning, and execution under the guidance of more senior PMs.
Intern Product Manager: While not a permanent position, interns can expect to earn around $24.48 per hour. These roles provide a stepping stone into the field, offering hands-on experience in product management processes.
Junior Product Manager: Junior PMs, with an average salary of $84,599 per year, handle more responsibilities than associate PMs, including managing smaller product features or projects.
Mid-Level Roles:
Product Manager: The core role in product management is that PMs earn an average of $120,872 annually, with a salary range between $75,676 and $193,059, depending on their experience, the complexity of the products they manage, and the size of the company.
Advanced Roles:
Senior Product Manager: As senior product managers, professionals earn an average of $152,781 per year. They take on larger products or multiple product lines, driving strategy and working closely with cross-functional teams to achieve product goals.
Principal Product Manager: At this level, the average salary jumps to $192,603 per year. Principal product managers have a strategic role, often guiding the overall product direction for the company, mentoring other PMs, and influencing major business decisions.
Highest Paying Locations: Product managers see the highest salaries in cities like Seattle, WA ($140,942 per year), Austin, TX ($133,272 per year), and New York, NY ($132,884 per year). These regions typically have a high demand for tech talent, which drives up the average pay for product management roles.
Why the Product vs. Project Manager Distinction Matters
Product Managers and Project Managers are like two sides of the same coin — they work together to bring great products to life. Product managers shape the vision and strategy, while project managers ensure that the vision gets executed efficiently.
They support and promote each other. The better they foster this relationship, the more they create a dynamic where product ideas turn into reality without a hitch.
This is why it’s crucial to know the difference. When you understand what each role brings to the table, you can get the right kind of support you need.
Product OKR Template
Use this Product OKR template to set and track your OKRs (Objectives and Key Results). Align your team’s daily tasks with product and company strategy!
get free template
Updated: September 30, 2024
